Register | Login | Forgot Password | RSS |
Home       |       Video       |       TheHoopsForum Radio       |       Ron Campbell       |       Marlon Benjamin       |       Harold       |       Steis  
  
Overrated

1/23/2008
Overrated I have been watching the NBA with regularity for the last 18 years. Over the years I have seen several stars come and go from O.J. Mayo to Larry Bird and Derrick Rose to Magic. By now I have figured out which players can possibly lead a team to the championship or even at least the NBA Finals. For some reason, I swear, the majority of the media still does not understand exactly what it takes to win an NBA championship. Several players are considered superstars, but I'm going to let you in on a little secret, they will never get it done for their organization. As far as I'm concerned, the next few championships will come down to L.A., Boston, Cleveland or Orlando. Here is a list of players that are masquerading as Championship level players.

1. Chris Bosh:
Scottie Pippen said it best when referring to Charles Barkley back when they were teammates on the Houston Rockets. Just because you score a lot of points and grab a lot of rebounds, doesn't mean you are doing everything for your team to win. You hear that Chris? It was recently reported that Chris Bosh publicly called Jemario Moon out for his poor defense late in a game and then called out the entire team for their lack of urgency on the defensive end. Well Chris Bosh is no candidate for the All Defensive team either and he is the team’s leader and best player. What Bosh needs to do is study tape of Tim Duncan and K.G. On Monday night Tim Duncan's Spurs escaped Charlotte with a 2 point win after Tim Duncan blocked a Raymond Felton's game tying shot attempt. Although I think K.G. is a little overrated, his defense is not. He is super intense when guarding players, tries to block as many shot as possible even if it results in a goal tend and often screams and yells on the defensive end just to get into the heads of other players. These are things Chris Bosh does not do. When they say K.G. changed the culture of the Celtics, he got all the Celtics amped up because his antics on the defensive end was contagious because he leads by example. Now if Chris Bosh made the same commitment on defense, maybe his teammates would follow suit. I guess Chris Bosh thinks yelling and public embarrassment works better. I wonder what he will wear for the NBA Draft Lottery in April.

2. Brandon Roy:
I watched Brandon Roy very closely Wednesday night in his match up with LeBron James, and I must say I'm impressed. The kid has the heart of Lion, but he doesn't have the game to match. Other then his first step, there is nothing even remotely athletic about this guy. He reminds me very much of Chauncey Billups. He missed like 5 or 6 lay-ups in the fourth quarter. The reason he was taking so many drives to the basket is because he cannot make a jumper off the dribble. He has no step back jumper at all either. He is a point guard, being forced to play the two. Also, we have all seen the commitments made by Wade, LeBron and Kobe on the defensive end. All three should be on the all-defensive team this season. When Roy attempted to put the clamps on LeBron last night, King James was able to run right by him. On one sequence they sent a second defender at LeBron to assist Roy and LeBron just ran circles around them for a left handed scoop lay up. With such poor defense and many holes on offense, I cannot imagine a scenario in which Brandon Roy leads his team to a championship. Not to mention, if Portland does manage to make the Finals, again I can't even imagine Roy getting the best of LeBron or Wade in a series. Portland should have drafted Durant 2 years ago.

3. Michael Redd:
Michael Redd is so one -dimensional, it is really a mystery why the Bucks insist on building around him. He has improved his defense and opened up his offense, but he still is not a player that can impose his will. I guess the thought was that Redd would have the same impact as Ray Allen had, but Ray is a much more complete player and capable of imposing his will. As the Bucks are constructed now, they are good enough to fight for the 8th seed and get swept in the first round. The Bucks need another big or slasher on the wing.

Name
Comment
Insert Cancel
NameComment
Stu Parkerwow. after reading this blog....You are spot on. I do not deny Kevin Garnett's ability as a player but HATE the BS stuff he does...All negative crap.
 This is a very unfair article. Garnett is an Olympic Gold Medalist, an MVP, an ALL STAR MVP, an ALL NBA member and an NBA Champion... you know how many current players can say that? 2 others (Shaq & Kobe) and they are all considered among the best players at their respected positions in the HISTORY of basketball. The same should be said for K.G.
 This is a very unfair article. Garnett is an Olympic Gold Medalist, an MVP, an ALL STAR MVP, an ALL NBA member and an NBA Champion... you know how many current players can say that? 2 others (Shaq & Kobe) and they are all considered among the best players at their respected positions in the HISTORY of basketball. The same should be said for K.G.
RaThis is blasphemy. I hope a Celtics fan did not write this article.
KWAPTHow old is that clip of KG? C'mon..of course that was a punk move, but what was that, 10 years ago? It's simple: KG is a fierce competitor who uses intimiadation and mental toughness to strike fear in the heart of his opponents. If he is on your team, you LOVE him. If he is not, you may loathe him. But either way, he is a great player. You cannot deny that.
AlexWow, now we are going to call an Olympic Gold Medalist, an MVP, an ALL STAR MVP, an ALL NBA member, an NBA Champion, a player that has more 20-10-5 seasons than Larry Bird, Defender of the Year (2008 and most likely, this year) overrated? Hmm, right now I'm kind of smelling a bit of jealousy mixed with stupidity in this article.
TweedsterThis blog is poorly written, scattered and incoherent. Thankfully, someone else already tackled the inconsistencies and leaps of logic. Check it out hear: http://celticshub.com/2009/10/22/did-you-hear-kg-is-overrated/
TweedsterSome actual statistics, and not just conjecture and strange conclusions based on the number of 'chips KG has. http://www.celticstown.com/is-kevin-garnett-clutch.html
SPron campbell must love the Lakers. Or the Cav's. Or the Magic. but he doesn't know @$@@ about basketball!
Ed The Sports FanI'm sorry, there's no way in life Allen Iverson isn't in the starting 5, especially ahead of Nash. Give a damn about MVP's, Iverson's done more with much much MUCH less and totally revolutionized the game. Other than that, I think your decade team is cool. -Ed.
Lebron is the KingThe way you analyzed your stats is flawed. If your saying Bird is better because he hits more 3 pointers, scores more, and passes more, your wrong. Bird had exceptional teammates which explains some assists. Now Bird was a great 3 point shooter and you said Duncan was a "center playing a power forward". Now if he does this, why would you bash it? All it shows is how versatile Duncan is in his position on the court. Duncan although not a flashy player, showed dominance under the goal. Duncan didnt need to pass because he could school anyone under the goal. Duncan is better because he has more rings. End of story. And to your comment on "We will never see another Larry Bird." Well we see a better one now, he goes by Ray Ray.
BOSTON CELTICS
2008 NBA Champions

Get Your News Widget
TheHoopsForum On Twitter
   Twitter NBA Roll Call
Aaron Brooks

Adonal Foyle

Al Harrington

Allen Iverson

Amare Stoudemire

Andre Iguodala

Andrew Bogut

Austin Daye

Baron Davis

Blake Griffin

Bostjan Nachbar

Brian Cardinal

Bruce Bowen

C.J. Miles

Cartier Martin

Chris Bosh

Chris Douglas Roberts

Chris Paul

Daequan Cook

Dahntay Jones

DaJuan Summers

Danny Granger

Deandre Jordan

DeJuan Blair

Demar DeRozan

Derek Fisher

Deron Williams

Donte Greene

Dorell Wright

Drew Gooden

Dwayne Wade

Dwight Howard

Eddy Curry

Eric Maynor

Fabricio Oberto

Francisco Garcia

Glen Davis

Hasheem Thabeet

Jack McClinton III

James Harden

Jared Dudley

Jarrett Jack

Jason Richardson

Jason Terry

Jason Thompson

JaVale McGee

Jermaine O'Neal

Jerome Henderson

Jerryd Bayless

Jodie Meeks

Joe Crawford

Joe Johnson

Johan Petro

Jon Brockman

Josh Howard

Julian Wright

Kevin Durant

Kevin Love

Kyle Lowry

Lamar Odom

Mario Chalmers

Mark Madsen

Michael Beasley

Mike Conley

Mike James

Mike Miller

Mo Williams

Morris Peterson

Nate Robinson

Nazr Mohammed

Nick Collison

Patty Mills

Paul Pierce

Quentin Richardson

Randy Foye

Rashard Lewis

Rashard McCants

Rasual Butler

Robin Lopez

Roger Mason Jr.

Ron Artest

Royal Ivey

Rudy Fernandez

Rudy Gay

Russell Westbrook

Ryan Gomes

Sasha Vujacic

Sean May

Shaquille O'Neal

Shelden Williams

Speedy Claxton

Stephen Curry

Stephon Marbury

Steve Nash

T.J. Ford

Terrance Williams

Thabo Sefolosha

Travis Outlaw

Trevor Ariza

Troy Murphy

Tyreke Evans

Tyson Chandler

Wayne Ellington

Opportunites | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Site Disclaimer | Mission | Terms of Use